Ben Affleck’s “Gone Baby Gone” based on Dennis (“Mystic River”) Lehane’s novel takes a police story and converts it into an examination of layers of evil and ethics. Moreover, if the person’s behaviour can determine the universal moral law, this behaviour or action is absolutely moral. Harris talks about cops being at war “and we’re not sinning.” The war is about values, or their death at the hands of a cruel culture. The movie, Gone, Baby, Gone, is a powerful analysis of morality set in the context of child abduction/kidnapping. Thus, Captain’s actions did not fully correspond to deontological ethics. 30 January. Amanda’s mother had been a drug mule, a drug user, stealing from a drug lord, etc, and she often did her craft either while her young daughter was with her, or while she was abandoning her altogether. In building the plot of the play, his decisions play a significant role. Company Registration No: 4964706. Patrick Kenzie is the main character who has to decide about the further life of the kidnapped girl Amanda. But whatever set of ethics that once held working class families together has dissolved along with the work discipline of factories, mines and mills. Do you have a 2:1 degree or higher? “Deontology, Consequentialism and Moral Realism.” Minerva – An Open Access Journal of Philosophy, vol. . “I always believed that it was the things you don’t chose that made you who you are . The mystery remains. I took pride in these things, like they were an accomplishment. Since he does not trust the instincts of Angie, who reacts properly when she risks her life to save the child earlier in the film, Patrick faces yet another moral dilemma. Thus, the life of Amanda in the family of Captain Doyle was almost perfect, and the intentions of Doyle were good because he wanted to demonstrate the better life to the girl. Love Will Find a Way Home: A Theology on the Ethics of Love. (2019, January 30). Ben Affleck’s “Gone Baby Gone” based on Dennis (“Mystic River”) Lehane’s novel takes a police story and converts it into an examination of layers of evil and ethics. VAT Registration No: 842417633. My post will be in three parts. He had no right to live.¿½ In addition, Kant also claims that, ¿½altruistic actions that result from feelings of sociability deserve praise and encouragement, but they cannot be classified as possessing strictly moral value.¿½ (Kant, 149) All things considered, Patrick as well as the society as a whole sees killing in order to save other children is the right behavior, however, Patrick knows for a fact that morally, it does not exhibit moral value. Registered office: Venture House, Cross Street, Arnold, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, NG5 7PJ. One of the major themes occurring often within our recent movies is the challenge of various aspects of motive and ethics. IvyPanda, 30 Jan. 2019, ivypanda.com/essays/the-moral-dilemma-in-gone-baby-gone/. Cookies Policy, The Morality of the Movie “Gone Baby Gone”, The Film “Remember the Titans”: Leadership Roles, The Social Worker Role in the Film “Crash”, The Marble Column from the Temple of Artemis at Sardis, “Christina’s World” Painting by Andrew Wyeth, “Miss Ever’s Boys” a Film by Joseph Sargent, The “Straight White Men” Play by Young Jean Lee.

Angie, however is still hesitant about involving herself in the investigation, as she says to Patrick, ¿½I don¿½t wanna find a little kid in a dumpster after they¿½ve been abused for three days.¿½ in which Patrick replies ¿½Hon, nobody does.¿½ There are many moral complications within the characters of the movie, in terms of both Patrick¿½s and Angie¿½s moral viewpoint. Who and what will stop the erosion other than rigid insistence on the venerable values of centuries, the ones Patrick learned in church? professional specifically for you? » IvyPanda. Hi thereThanks for sharing, I have digged this post, Gone Baby Gone (Afleck, 2007): Moral Dilemma for the Righteous. January 30, 2019. https://ivypanda.com/essays/the-moral-dilemma-in-gone-baby-gone/. When what we feel doesn't match what we believe. It’s hard raising a family, you know. Patrick¿½s character defies logic and reason when he willingly returns Amanda back to her family, even though he knows the child would be better off with Jack. When the daughter of Helen got lost, Patrick Kenzie is offered an opportunity to take the lead in the search for the baby. Even Lionel, who plays Helene¿½s brother says to not feel sorry for her sister, as she does not care for anybody else. From simple essay plans, through to full dissertations, you can guarantee we have a service perfectly matched to your needs. Moral value is essentially established by the intention of the person acting. I would come across as noise or static. “This ain’t no strip-clubbin in Lynn, Patrick. ( Log Out / 

When she is found, she appears not only unharmed, but quite content, havening been taken from her dead-beat mother for her own well-being. Surprisingly, the aim of the kidnappers was not to harm the baby but to protect the baby from her irresponsible mother. Author House, 2007. Or has “Nature” become corrupted by malodorous customs in which rigid rules make little sense? Patrick is enraged and shoots Corwin in the back of his head while he pleaded for mercy. From this point of view, the person’s behaviour can be discussed as moral when any other person can act the same way in similar circumstances. This is IvyPanda's free database of academic paper samples. The most moral people in the sick society accept responsibility for their behavior and take the consequences, no matter how unpleasant. 1st Jan 1970 Pop Art and a Post-Christian Culture (part 2), Pop Art and a Post-Christian Culture (1 of 2), Marriage vs. Cohabitation? He told me what God said to His children; ‘Though I send you as sheep among wolves, you must be wise as serpents yet innocent as doves.’”. In modern working class Boston, the foundations of “good” have eroded with “competition,” which Bush claims “brings out the best in everybody.” This has meant union busting and withdrawal of government services and regulatory agencies that once checked corporate irresponsibility. Gone Baby Gone. Greene, Joshua D. “The Secret Joke of Kant’s Soul.” Moral Psychology: Historical and Contemporary Readings, edited by Thomas Nadelhoffer, Eddy Nahmias, and Shaun Nichols, Wiley-Blackwell, 2010, pp. “I always believed that it was the things you don’t chose that made you who you are . For full functionality of this site it is necessary to enable JavaScript. As Patrick looks for motive inside this druggy, boozy, criminal culture, he finds that crime goes with addiction as white goes with rice. In their detectives’ world of dubious moral crevices, they could easily lose their own ethical center. The movie makes the viewers consider what is right and what is wrong. To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below: If you are the original writer of this essay and no longer wish to have your work published on the UKDiss.com website then please: Our academic writing and marking services can help you! Look how far they have fallen! “Do you even give a f*** about your kid?” She explains to the cop, “It’s really hard being a [single] motha.
I don’t want to point out that my answers come from a book of authoritative answers that society no longer acknowledges. Affleck co-wrote the screenplay with Aaron Stockard based on the 1998 novel Gone, Baby, Gone by Dennis Lehane.



Murder is a sin.¿½ In which Remy responds by saying, ¿½depends on who you do it to.¿½ Patrick says, ¿½No, that¿½s not how it works, it is what it is.¿½ Patrick is applying the universal concept that murder is wrong, no matter to whom it is to. Gone Baby Gone is a 2007 American neo-noir mystery crime thriller film directed by Ben Affleck, in his feature-length directorial debut. Director Affleck (also co-author with Aaron Stockard of the screenplay) makes the neighborhood heavies advance the plot, while planting the seeds of an ethical dilemma. . In my opinion, Patrick has made a wrong choice. "The Moral Dilemma in Gone Baby Gone." 260-270. The setting could have been any dark corner of anyplace in urban America, because the theme is universal—what is easy is usually not what is right. She would have a caring family and would have grown in a positive environment. » Gone Baby Gone (Afleck, 2007): Moral Dilemma for the Righteous. From this point on, after Patrick takes the responsibility and goes forth his investigation, the film only gets more gloomy and harsh. Durante más de 40 años, el TNI ha actuado como un punto de interconexión entre movimientos sociales, académicos y académicas comprometidos y responsables de políticas.
It not only questions the characters in the movie, but the audience in asking themselves, ¿½how can we choose between what is good and what is morally right?¿½ In order to get a better grasp of the question at hand, Kant¿½s ideas of duty and reason provides us with a foundation … We can look to the doctrines of Kant and focus our attention to the characters of the movie to further explain the moral situations seen by the movie by analyzing Kant¿½s doctrines of good will, duty, reason, maxim, and the categorical and practical imperatives.

Copyright © 2020 - IvyPanda is a trading name of Edustream Technologies LLC, a company registered in Wyoming, USA. Such an example in the movie is shown deliberately when Patrick makes the choice of murdering the child molester, Corwin Earle. To Kant, ¿½good will represents the effort of rational beings to do what they ought to do rather than to act from inclination or self interest.¿½ (Kant, 145) Early in the movie, both Angie and Patrick are faced with a decision to whether or not get involved in the case of the abduction of Amanda McCready. May, Joshua. Oscar Nominations: It's like Christmas, without pr... Inglourious Basterds: nigh time for a Jewish reven... Glenn Close talks Alex Forrest and mental illness. On the movie posters to this movie, the tag line read: However, justifying deontology is a complicated matter (Slote 260). Therefore, Patrick’s decision to take Amanda back to her mother is dictated by his responsibility as a law-abiding citizen. It’s a small sub-plot, but we’re also suppose to feel sympathy for the mother who feels trapped in her life as though the choices were being made for her. There was a funny comment on this post, but sadly it has to be removed due to its advertising content.No ad for you. I don’t want to try to answer the questions being raised.

745-755. "The Moral Dilemma in Gone Baby Gone." Freud and his mother: the Oedipus complex in The D... Are you feelin' the love? See part two of this post. Thus, the pattern of avoiding the family problems with the help of kidnapping can be followed globally because such a situation is discussed as moral in the case of kidnapping Amanda. The maxima of Kant’s moral theory are based on the idea of the categorical imperative and the person’s duty to act according to the universal moral laws. We utilize security vendors that protect and ensure the integrity of our platform while keeping your private information safe. Her grip on reality checks his dangerous impulses. Patrick, with gun drawn, looks around the room and sees evidence that the boy was molested and abused before his murder.